“HAPPY HOLLANDAISE! Mayo Heart Be Light……”

As you plan your menus for Christmas and New Year’s, Chef Andy Mueller – of Galley 57 Supper Club – has a deliciously tempting suggestion!

Considered the top dog in all the Mother Sauces, Hollandaise seems to have the ability to turn nothing special into something spectacular.  Joining Espagnole (brown sauces), Veloute (chicken, pork or veal sauces), Bechamel (White sauces) and Tomato sauces, Hollandaise usually gets the nod when a chef wants to turn something decent into something decadent.


You’ve probably had Eggs Benedict at some point in your life and I’m sure you’ve had mayonnaise on a sandwich or in a salad more times than you can remember.  Both are part of the mother sauce category that calls for some type of emulsion between eggs and some type of fat, be it butter in Hollandaise, or oil in mayo.  

When blended at a high rate of speed, the fat and the egg create an emulsion that results in a creamy, almost velvety sauce that not only pleases the palate, but takes almost any food to the next level.

The difficulty level in making a proper Hollandaise falls in the “moderate” category as you do need to be able to walk and chew gum at the same time.

By this I mean you need to be able to do two things at once (drizzle butter or oil with one hand and whisk vigorously with the other).  Of course, you can grab a partner and split duties, just make sure you keep a steady pace until finished with the sauce.

Temperature also plays a big role in the emulsion process.  With Hollandaise sauce, the butter needs to be at a hot enough temperature to suspend the sauce, it can’t be too hot as to cook the eggs.  If the butter is too hot, the eggs will scramble and your sauce will be ruined.

With mayonnaise, the eggs can’t be too cold or the emulsion will not happen and you’ll be left with a broken mess. 

Follow the recipe for Bernaise Sauce below.  It’s a “Blender” version of Hollandaise that’s great on baked chicken, veal, or that roast beast you’re planning on serving for the holidays.

Bernaise Sauce

In a Food Processor or Blender add:

4 egg yolks
1/2 tsp. sriracha hot sauce
1 Tblsp. lemon juice
pinch salt
1 Tblsp. rice wine vinegar
1 tsp. chopped fresh tarragon

In a small sauce pan over medium to medium high heat add:

12 Tblsp butter

Melt butter and stir it until it just starts to boil. 

With the food processor running at lowest speed, slowly drizzle in the hot melted butter in a steady stream until the sauce thickens.  Do not over process.  If the sauce starts to break, the butter is too hot.  Add an ice cube and lightly process to bring the sauce back to life. 

Serve over roast beef, prime rib or grilled chicken.  Enjoy!

Galley 57 Will Have Special Hours for Christmas Week:

Normal hours (Tues-Sat, 4pm-9pm) through Saturday, December 22nd.  We will be closed Sunday, Monday (Christmas Eve), Tuesday (Christmas Day), and Wednesday, December 26th.  Back to normal hours Thursday, Friday, and Saturday (27th, 28th and 29th).  We WILL be open New Year’s Eve – Monday, December 31st.

Chef Andy suggests Reservations for any evening, but especially if you plan to join them for New Year’s Eve – They’re filling up quickly!

Galley 57

It’s a Wisconsin supper club tradition to visit with friends, neighbors, and co-workers for a drink before dinner.  Chef Andy likes to say: “what’s old is cool again.”  His parents’ generation enjoyed drinks like old fashioneds (whiskey or brandy).  That tradition was lost by a generation, but now “old fashioned” drinks like these are in fashion again!  Young professionals and older adults alike are calling Galley 57 the “home of the $3 old fashioned.”  That’s right, every dinner is special at Galley 57 when it kicks off with a homemade old fashioned.  One of the secrets (not anymore) to a great old fashioned is the cherry.  Galley 57 uses only the finest cherries.  You won’t find a store-bought maraschino cherry in your old fashioned at Galley 57, rather you will delight in a drink with a wild Italian Amarena cherry.  If you’ve never tried one, come in for a taste test!