The Sides Have It!

With Thanksgiving coming up quickly, Chef Andy Mueller, of Galley 57 Supper Club, has a delicious recipe to share!


I don’t know what I look forward to more, the beautiful bird waiting to be carved on Thanksgiving Day, or the obnoxious amount of all things “carb-aliscious” surrounding it.

Is it the mashed potatoes with the rich gout gravy, the sage kissed dressing with the burnt edges, or the earthy sweet yams covered in marshmallows just hot enough to destroy the roof of your mouth.

The answer to all of the above is a resounding yes and a double scoop of each to go!

I have to time it right as I get a little longer in the tooth. As a young egg cracker, I could fill up one leg with turkey and the other with all the fixins’, then hook up an IV with gravy and go play football with the neighbors til dark. Nowadays, If I even say the word turkey I get a little sleepy and hope there’s a couch nearby.

The quandary I now face is still trying to achieve Thanksgiving food coma levels without forcing too many carbs down in the process. Every year my helpings of potatoes and dressing get smaller, and my new favorite filler (apples and acorn squash), gets a little bigger.

It’s not a dramatic reduction in carbs, it’s more of a mental game of trading savory carbs with sweet and savory carbs, and that somehow makes sense in my mind this time of year. It’s also not quite as heavy, so this little game of nonsensical culinary math allows me to basically feel OK doing nothing short of a full-on face plant into a larger than it should be piece of pumpkin pie.

Grandma Kathy, or “G-K” as she’s known to my sons, has been serving this apple baked acorn squash since I was a still lickin’ batter off the wooden spoon (still do, just thought it was good imagery). It’s as easy as anything you’ll make this Thanksgiving, and It’s savory enough to fit on the main plate, yet sweet enough to keep you from diving onto the dessert table before everyone’s finished with their meal. One more move like that and it’s back to the kiddie table for you! Happy Thanksgiving!

Baked Acorn Squash with Apples

Preheat oven to 375 degrees. Cut two medium-sized acorn squash in half from stem to stern and carve out the seeds and threads. In the dug out center of each squash half add:

1 tsp. butter
1 tsp brown sugar
1/8 tsp cinnamon
1/4 cup diced apples (honey crisp, gala, braeburn are best)

Top with:

1 tsp. butter
1 tsp. brown sugar
1/8 tsp. cinnamon

Wrap each half with foil to cover tightly, place foil-wrapped squash in a baking dish and bake for 1 hour. Acorn squash is done when soft. To check if they are done, insert a long skewer into the squash through the foil and into the squash. If it pokes through easily, it is done. If it is still firm, bake another fifteen minutes or until tender. Remove the squash from the oven. Carefully remove the foil and transfer squash to a serving bowl.

Squash and apples will be volcanic, please devour carefully!


Stop in, enjoy a great meal in a relaxed atmosphere, say hello to Chef Andy, and please let him know that the Green Bay News Network sent you!

Galley 57

It’s a Wisconsin supper club tradition to visit with friends, neighbors, and co-workers for a drink before dinner.  Chef Andy likes to say: “what’s old is cool again.”  His parents’ generation enjoyed drinks like old fashioneds (whiskey or brandy).  That tradition was lost by a generation, but now “old fashioned” drinks like these are in fashion again!  Young professionals and older adults alike are calling Galley 57 the “home of the $3 old fashioned.”  That’s right, every dinner is special at Galley 57 when it kicks off with a homemade old fashioned.  One of the secrets (not anymore) to a great old fashioned is the cherry.  Galley 57 uses only the finest cherries.  You won’t find a store-bought maraschino cherry in your old fashioned at Galley 57, rather you will delight in a drink with a wild Italian Amarena cherry.  If you’ve never tried one, come in for a taste test!